Budget Must Address India’s Reputation Problem

One of the least enviable jobs in the world at the moment has to be that of Indian finance minister. Arun Jaitley will present his fourth annual budget to India’s Parliament on Wednesday amid terrible headwinds — mostly caused by his government’s bewildering and disruptive decision to invalidate 86 percent of India’s currency last November. If he’s to revive growth, the first thing he has to do is rethink his priorities.

The scale of the challenge should be clear. The government’s official estimate of 7.1 percent GDP growth this financial year (which began in April) is widely doubted and doesn’t take into account the chaos wrought by demonetization. The International Monetary Fund predicts growth will come in closer to 6.6 percent, or a full percentage point below earlier estimates. And these numbers conceal even more weaknesses. Most glaringly, Indian investment has shrunk for the last three quarters for which reliable data is available.

Under Prime Minister Narendra Modi, the government’s growth strategy has rested on two fundamental assumptions. First, there’s the unshakeable belief that India is so attractive a destination for capital, given the weakness in the rest of the world, all the government needs to do is tweak the investment climate and money will pour in.

Second is the idea that scaling up public spending, especially on infrastructure, will raise returns sufficiently to attract private investors — “crowding in,” as it’s known. The last three budgets — which, in India, are the year’s major statement of economic policy, not just simple accounting exercises — have operated on this principle.

Surely, however, Jaitley has noticed that this approach hasn’t worked. Even before the demand destruction caused by demonetization, India’s growth was hovering at or around the levels set in the last few years of the previous government’s tenure, when the investment crisis first hit. Clearly, companies aren’t “crowding in” as the government had hoped.

Meanwhile, Jaitley’s earlier budgets benefited hugely from low oil prices, which allowed the government to eliminate fuel subsidies while quietly raising taxes on gasoline to help pad its accounts and pay for a sharp increase in spending. Further declines in crude oil prices are hardly likely to come to the government’s rescue this year. At the same time, other calls on the purse have grown: Modi is likely to want a few giveaways in the budget to appease those hurt most badly by demonetization.

So, Jaitley may have to turn off the tap to the public infrastructure investment that’s been underpinning even the modest growth seen so far. He’s in a bind. He desperately needs to revive growth and investment. But he won’t have the money for his preferred strategy, which wasn’t working all that well anyway.

Unless the budget acknowledges this and sharply shifts focus, it’ll be a failure. India needs infrastructure and it needs investment, but only private capital can provide both. Jaitley’s priority thus has to be to create incentives for long-term capital to enter India.

How can he do that? Well, first he’ll have to recognize that, “bright spot in the world economy” or not, India is still seen as too much of a risk. This reputation is primarily related to policy and administration. Simply put, you’re still too likely to lose your money in India if some officer of the state decides you should.

Modi’s government has hardly altered this perception. Investors have noted that they might be told that they can’t take their money out once they put it in: The government acted to prevent the Japanese company NTT Docomo, for example, from getting the roughly $1 billion it was owed for exiting a contract with Tata Teleservices.

Nor do investors have much recourse in the face of arbitrary state action. The Indian court system is slow and overburdened. Companies have turned for relief to international arbitration. But Modi’s government has tried to close off even that avenue, declaring that 57 bilateral investment treaties that enshrine international arbitration would be renegotiated to ensure the primacy of Indian courts.

Jaitley’s budget will have to reverse this trend. He’ll have to announce wide-ranging reform of tax administration, as well as quicker and more transparent ways for investors to appeal judgments. He’ll have to show that the government now understands that money will only come into India if it’s allowed to leave and if investors believe disputes will be fairly settled. And he’ll have to show he’s serious about lowering the risks India poses as an investment destination, perhaps by announcing an infrastructure project pipeline that’s open for investment and in which the government will bear any risks arising from arbitrary state actions.

That’s Jaitley’s only chance to reverse the investment collapse that’s happened under his watch. A budget like the three previous ones simply won’t be good enough.

This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.

To contact the author of this story: Mihir Sharma at m.s.sharma@gmail.comTo contact the editor responsible for this story: Nisid Hajari at

is it safe to sleep on my back during pregnancyWalter McGowan fought in a long forgotten and bloody decade when British boxers won, lost and progressed only after taking risks in fights that seem ridiculous by modern standards. Wee Walter, as the ’60s hacks occasionally referred to him, turned professional at 18 after cheap nfl jerseys just two defeats in 124 Replica ray bans fights as an amateur in Scotland. He was guided by his father Thomas, who had fought as a professional using the name of American legend Joe Gans; the original Gans crammed 176 bouts into an extraordinary career and was the first black world champion.Reporter: Few would have expected Coleman to wind up here, deaf since childhood he’s the only third hearing impaired player to reach the NFL. At what point cheap oakleys sunglasses did you realize you were different? Honestly, I never truly realized that I’m different, I just accepted who I am. Reporter: But some of the kids treated you differently. Many stage shows and early movies rendered the chant, however today it has become the living breathing entity that can link all New Orleans Saints fans to one another forever! You can be in restaurant in California and hear those two words, “Who Dat?” and instantly your head swings around making eye contact with the speaker and you know, without another word you are in the company of a New Orleans Saints fan!In a recent survey by Men’s Health Week, out of 1,500 men questioned, 40 per cent blamed stress for poor sexual performance.With this in mind, we’ve found five natural cures to help reduce stress, increase blood flow and restore potency in your sex life.The extract from the leaves of ginkgo biloba, also known as the Chinese maidenhair tree, is recommended for circulation problems, low energy levels and general fatigue. Replica ray ban Sunglasses sale And a lot wholesale china jerseys of them are uncomfortable with, you know, what he could have been, you know, thinking about the entire time or anything like that. But, you know, given the fact that there’s not that many people in, you know, college and professional athletics, you know, it’s just very difficult for a lot of people to, you know, kind of think from that point of view as to, you know, what they would do jordan sale or how they would handle the situation because you really don’t know how people would handle it once you get, you know, everybody sitting in the locker room, people that you spend years with, you know, a lot of time with and, you know, occasionally live with and stuff cheap ray ban Sunglasses Online like that that, you know, they really have no idea, you know, what it coming from that angle is. So.
The spurt of good scores despite unkind weather four golfers posted 66 in the second round gave room for a new theory. Six were registered on the Center for Missing and Exploited Children website. Develop an overall coaching philosophy and demonstrate it during your job interview. These brand initiatives along with the addition of Granville Island volume and incremental sales from the Vancouver Winter Olympics held in February, helped us to increase our market share a 0.5 a point versus a year ago.. Even if you don’t know the fan that you’re buying a gift for very well, but you know their hometeam, you can surprise them Replica Air Jordans with a discounted Green Bay Packers NFL jacket and watch their face light up wholesale nfl jersyes with joy and surprise! These NFL jackets are nice enough to be worn out cheap nfl jerseys wholesale to a semi fancy dinner and perfect for lounging around the yard on a cold day.. From Mitch Skate shoes to Hooper oakleys outlet Flip Flops there are shoes fit for skateboarding to chilling on the beach. 83 games! What a pitiful win percentage for a playoff team (.512). While they garnered much social media attention, The Shire and Being Lara Bingle are examples of underwhelming reality TV. So, there is a lot of information on the card, learning how to read it is essential. The players have to keep changing directions while running. In an attempt to condone this behavior, the Supreme Court even decided that state regulations don’t apply to Native land or its residents. With 2 ms temporal resolution, the IOSs were unambiguously detected as early as at 4 ms (Fig. When Bonds’ career ended after the 2007 season, he was indicted for perjury and obstruction of justice in the BALCO steroids scandal. ESPN said the block by Garvin is under review by the league. Bellefonte is the county seat of Centre county, full of history and Victorian beauty with charming vintage shoppes and great local food venues. The Hayne model is after the fashion of Sonny Bill Williams and Israel Folau whereby you simply take your skills to the market place and happily knock yourself down to the highest bidder, no matter what sport it is, be it league, union, boxing, NFL, AFL, sevens, whatever. Aside from the companies that will benefit directly from the tournament, I thought it would be fun to look at companies headquartered or with a large presence in each of the countries. So now all porn in Japan has the genitals pixelated out.. The Packers are a victory away from clinching the NFC North title after beating the Lions 27 20.

Related Articles

Back to top button