Ernie Barnes’ ‘Sugar Shack’ painting brings big price at auction

Ernie Barnes’ most famous painting, “The Sugar Shack,” an exultant dancing scene that was featured on the cover of Marvin Gaye’s album “I Want You” and during the closing credits of the TV sitcom “Good Times,” sold for a whopping $15.3 million at Chrie’s 20th Century auction on Thursday evening to energy trader Bill Perkins. It was 76 times its high estimate of $200,000.
“I stole it — I would have paid a lot more,” said Perkins, 53, in telephone interview after the sale. “For certain segments of America, it’s more famous than the ‘Mona Lisa.’ ”
Though based in Houston, Perkins said he did not want to risk being on the phone, so he flew to New York City with his fiance, Lara Sebastian, to attend the sale in person. He was worried that he might be outbid someone of greater means. “What if Oprah shows up? What if P. Diddy shows up?” he recalled thinking. “I’m not going to be able to buy this piece.”

Should anything happen to hinder Perkins at the auction, he said, he and Sebastian had a plan. “I said, ‘Hey, babe, if I have a problem or I pass out, do not worry about me: Keep bidding.’ ”
Perkins was amazed the extent of the competition, which drew a total of 22 bidders and took 10 minutes. “It started and it just went nuts,” he said.
In the end, the bidding came down to Perkins vs. someone else in the room — art adviser Gurr Johns, according to art reporter Josh Baer — who was bidding on behalf of an unidentified person on the phone.
“He turns to me at one point and says, ‘I’m not going to stop,’ ” Perkins said of Johns. “To which I replied, ‘Then I’m going to make you pay.’ ”
The staggering price — more than double that of a Cézanne in the sale, and more than a Monet and a de Kooning — reflected not only the rarity of Barnes’ image, which was painted in 1976, but also the heightened interest for work Black arts at a time when the art world has woken up to issues of diversity and made a strong commitment to expanding the canon.
Barnes, a former football player who died in 2009, was known for his kinetic drawings and paintings of athletes, dancers and other figures.
Perkins, who was raised in Jersey City, New Jersey, where his father, an attorney, and his mother, an educator, owned several works abstract art Norman Lewis, said the Barnes painting — which he saw featured on Gaye’s album and “Good Times” — was formative in his artic consciousness. “You never saw paintings of Black people Black arts,” he said. “This introduced not just me but all of America to Barnes’ work. It’s the only artwork that has ever done that. And these were firsts. So this is never going to happen again. Ever. The cultural importance of this piece is just crazy.”
Perkins said he was educated about art in part Rick Lowe, the Houston-based art and community organizer, whose Project Row Houses have become a leading example of social practice art. He said he has some other Barnes works, as well as those Charles White.
Lowe talked about how “the role of the collector is to send a signal of what is important to museums and the world,” Perkins said. “I took this to heart; OK, I am now the defender of certain things, this is my role — to be a steward of certain pieces of art and also have fun doing it.”
He has collected work Black arts whose value the world had yet to fully recognize. “I’m not the art horian, I’m not the art genius, but I know markets,” he said. “And I know when something is way, way, way out of whack.”

The Barnes was a prime example of that, Perkins said.
He added that he hoped to loan the Barnes painting to a museum so the public could enjoy it before the work holds pride of place in his home — where “I can see it every day and soak up the memory dividend and the happy absurdity that I can own it.”
Female arts also fared well Thursday night, namely Howardena Pindell, whose work of sewn canvas squares sold for $1.3 million (estimate $300,000 to $500,000); Ruth Asawa, whose brass and copper wire work sold for nearly $2 million (estimate $800,000 to $1,200,000); and Grace Hartigan, whose colorful abstract “Early November” sold for $1.4 million (estimate $800,000 to $1.2 million).
The auction’s blue-chip arts brought solid prices, including Monet, Van Gogh and Pollock. But there were a few surprises, namely Emanuel Leutze’s grand “Washington Crossing the Delaware,” which sold for $45 million, more than twice its high estimate of $20 million.
A 1909 Picasso bronze cast, “Head of a Woman (Fernande),” brought $48.5 million for the Metropolitan Museum of Art’s acquisition fund, having recently been deaccessioned the museum and expected to sell for $30 million.
Perkins said he could have bought a Cézanne or de Kooning at Chrie’s on Thursday evening. But he was focused only on the Barnes. “I’ve been waiting like 40 years for this moment,” he said. “I’m not going to let it pass.”
This article originally appeared in The New York Times.
📣 For more lifestyle news, follow us on Instagram | Twitter | Facebook and don’t miss out on the latest updates!